After struggling and losing his wand to ron, pettigrews silver hand, which was gifted to him by voldemort, betrays him and strangles pettigrew. Jul 17, 2011 in the book, snape gives harry his memories with his wand as is the norm. I thought the movie was great and now find it interesting how they interpreted the book into the movie. She does take issue with the book s depiction of her son, marine lance cpl. Mar 10, 2003 jarhead by anthony swofford in this selflacerating memoir, an exmarine sniper who fought in the gulf yearns to escape from the myths of warfare and the sadism of military life. Jarhead addresses these questions in the microcosm of swoffords experience in desert storm and confronts us with a startling answer. Often times when i read a book then watch the movie it never lives up. Because of the constant change of the directing staff it was impossible to create a complete picture. Jarhead the selfimposed moniker of the marines follows swoff gyllenhaal, a thirdgeneration enlistee, from a sobering stint in boot camp to active duty, sporting a snipers rifle and a hundredpound ruck on his back through middle east deserts with no cover from intolerable heat or from iraqi soldiers, always potentially just over the next horizon.
Film, i feel i should preface it with my personal feelings on adaptations. We had watched the movie jarhead on dvd basically because my husband is exmarine and watches most military related movies. Events in the book definitely do not happen in the same order as the movie. Book ginny was a completely different person than movie ginny. Did you put your name in the goblet of fire, harry. Jarhead recounts swoffords enlistment and service in the united states marine corps during the persian gulf war, in which he served as a scout sniper trainee with the. Jarhead, based on the book jarhead by anthony swofford, is considered one of the most accurate war movies to date. Anthony swoffords jarhead is the first gulf war memoir by a frontline infantry marine, and it is a searing, unforgettable narrative when the marines or jarheads, as they call themselves were sent in 1990 to saudi arabia to fight the iraqis, swofford was there, with a hundredpound pack on his shoulders and a snipers rifle in his hands. Harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban this unnecessary object was added to the knight bus. After leaving military service, the author went on to college and earned. Nov 03, 2005 although he signed the funeral guest book, she has no memory of one certain marine anthony swofford, author of jarhead, a gritty account of the gulf war and now a major movie, opening friday.
Harry meets dumbledore at a restaurant in the train station. Feb 21, 2008 i am a huge fan of harry potter and it disappoints me to know that the good scenes are taking out of the movie. Things happen in this one uses different characters but follows the originals theme about how it is awesome to be a united states marine. The film was released on november 4, 2005, by universal pictures. I found her more detestable because imelda staunton managed to be the embodiment of the horror that is dolores umbridge. Some people will prefer reading books and other will prefer watching movies. Ron, hermione and harry are together at the three broomsticks inn when they overhear fudge discussing sirius and james connection to each other. When you ask people whether they prefer movies or books, you are likely to get a variety of replies. Its been said hollywood milks every franchise to death to make an extra buck.
The movie never shows the relevance of this moment, but in the book, when pettigrew goes to the chamber where harry and ron are being kept by the malfoys, the deed comes full circle. Rita skeeter as an animagus there are a lot of things left out of the movie version of harry potter and the. But, i thought, why not try hollywoods spin on jarhead, a book i and. Its a shame, however, that jarhead seems to attempt too much at certain points, and this is the only aspect that hinders it from being a perfect movie. To be sure, those who know the corps will doubt many of the movies. Jarhead by anthony swofford in this selflacerating memoir, an exmarine sniper who fought in the gulf yearns to escape from the myths of warfare and the sadism of military life. Jun 01, 2018 jarhead is an allstar forgotten masterpiece, from 2005. The unique thing about the book, harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban, is. Harry is alone and invisible when he overhears the conversation. Differences between harry potter and the half blood prince. That is not the case with jarhead 2 following the military classic jarhead, based on the book by anthony swofford, jarhead 2. I found movie umbridge more detestable than book umbridge. Harry potter and the half blood prince that was not in the book.
In the book, ginny was sassy, powerful, and independent in harry potter and the order of the phoenix she says that. But that does not mean it was a great movie of the book. Whether because they split the final book in half or its just one of the easiest to translate to the screen, harry potter and the deathly hallows part 1 is the movie most loyal to the book its. There were talks initially of making harry potter and the goblet of fire into two movies since the book is more than 700 pages, but the filmmakers opted instead to cut some of the background. In the book, harry and the gryffindor team overcome harrys firstever honest loss in quidditch during the match against hufflepuff and cedric diggory in which he fell off his broom due to the dementors, the one scene the movie does show, to win the quidditch cup for the first time in ten years by beating slytherin. Jul, 2015 book ginny vs movie ginny i know that this topic has been discussed at length and im sure that a million people have done so better than me, but all the same, ive been wanting to vent about this since i started my blog so what better time to do so than harry potter month. What plot points are missing in the harry potter movies that. But in the movie, it was cho who told, under the vertislemen. Only a true potterhead will get 2020 on this books and. As a result, major, specific spoilers for both versions abound, often including dissection of how they end. There are direct lines and dialog, word for word from the book that also appear in the movie.
In the movie the dursleys are still part of harry s life. This column is meant largely for people whove already been through one version, and want to know how the other compares. As film critics have noted, it helped that swoffords book was published shortly before the assault on baghdad, but that might not help the movie. That scene is in my book, not tonys, he added, referring to mr. The true story behind jarhead greenville mom takes issue.
Rowling brought us the world of harry potter and endowed it with an impressive number of secrets. There is another interesting phenomena and that is a section of the population that enjoy both equally. Jarhead chronicles swoffords life story, as he is serving in the gulf war period. Jarhead the selfimposed moniker of the marines follows swoff, a thirdgeneration enlistee, from a sobering stint in boot camp to. Anthony swofford joined the us marine corps at the age of 17. Differences between harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban. In the book, ginny was sassy, powerful, and independent in harry potter and the order of. Top 10 differences between the hp books and movies what did. Film is a column comparing books to the film adaptations they spawn, often discussing them on a plotpointbyplotpoint basis. Seeing it on the screen was what made the movie scarier, i think. Book hermione had very clear flaws that the movie version didnt have, which i believe enhanced her charcter view entire discussion 54 comments. In the book, there are two more challenges a troll, which has already been knocked out when the three get to him, and a set of potions by snape, along with a riddle.
I love a great adaptation, but i also believe that getting the best movie from a good book rarely means sticking slavishly to the source material. After leaving military service, the author went on to college and earned a double masters degree in fine arts at the university of iowa. After leaving military service, the author went on to college and earned a double masters degree in fine arts at the university of iowa plot. Jarhead is an allstar forgotten masterpiece, from 2005. Harry potter and the adaptation from novel to film.
Feb 14, 2016 unless you want a phoenix clawing you eyes, never question dumbledore. Harry potter movies were made under rowlings personal observation. Jarhead is a 2005 american biographical war drama film based on u. Jarhead is a 2003 gulf war memoir by author and former u. A marines chronicle of the gulf war by anthony swofford scribner. In the book version of goblet of fire, rita skeeter is an unregistered animagus, who can turn into a beetle to eavesdrop on harry and his friends. Mar 28, 2014 in the movie, harry, hermione and ron only have to get past fluffy, through the room with the flying keys, and the chess game before harry gets to the final room with quirrell. A little later on in the game there was another commercial for the film. Jarhead is a war movie about a generation of soldiers who grew up watching war movies which only reminds us how superior those first.
His memoir tells of the misery of training, a faithless girlfriend, boredom, the temptations of suicide, a near shooting of a comrade, and near death in a boobytrapped iraqi bunker. In the movie, hagrid takes harry to the train station straight from shopping at diagon alley. Jarhead november 6th, 2005 sam mendes warfromasoldierspointofview movie hits some high notes, particularly as a technical exercise, but. Mar 25, 2011 in my opinion a book can ruin a movie but a movie can never ruin a book. Top 10 shocking differences between the harry potter movies and. Unless you want a phoenix clawing you eyes, never question dumbledore.
What if the characters of harry potter looked like they did in the books. Oct 05, 20 harry potter and the philosophers stone. This has always been amusing to me in the book the sorcerersphilosophers stone neville goes into the woods with harry, hermione, draco and hagrid in the ssps. The book fills in a bit more detail and background info on some of the. Movie october 5, 20 february 21, 2014 if youve only seen the harry potter movies and havent read the books, than there a few things that you might not know.
Book harry has a more takecharge attitude but is significantly more whiney. But if i watch the movie and enjoy it i find myself wanting to know more about the world and characters and i have never read a book after a movie and been disappointed. Jarhead not in the class of war movies it admires kitsap sun. Marine anthony swoffords 2003 memoir of the same name, directed by sam mendes, starring jake gyllenhaal as swofford with jamie foxx, peter sarsgaard, lucas black and chris cooper. This was normal for soldiers and marines in my personal experience as a soldier. Dumbledore goes to privet drive to pick him up before the start of school. Jarhead the selfimposed moniker of the marines follows swoff, a thirdgeneration enlistee, from a sobering stint in boot camp to active duty, sporting a snipers rifle and a hundredpound. The book fills in a bit more detail and background info on some of the other characters in the movie, and what happened to them after their military service was over etc. All harry potter movies differ from each other in the atmosphere. Harry potter and the adaptation from novel to film the. I dont know if you watch closely enough as i do, but in the 5 book, chos best friend was the one who told ms. I recall they had quite a bit to do in the movie, but they also had free time. However, it is apparently also possible to do so in the form of a tear as it was shown in the film, where harry scooped it up in a phial handed to him by hermione, as opposed to the book, where she conjures it from thin air. In the book, he goes back to the dursleys for a month after all, his birthday is july 31, and there is still a month of summer left.
1279 649 548 982 876 1402 604 1631 540 87 805 1540 318 748 1407 1061 404 213 797 996 784 394 898 742 749 1428 1161 764 521 131 1336 1133 1113 282